The Cost of Legacy 802.11b Rates

1, 2, 5.5 and 11 Mbps are 802.11b rates from 1999. They only exist on 2.4 GHz, and leaving them enabled costs airtime in three ways: slow beacons, slow clients that hold everyone back, and protection frames in front of every modern frame. Pick the lowest basic rate and see what each one costs.

Lowest basic rate (beacons, probe responses, management frames)
802.11b on 802.11b off

1 · Beacons at the lowest rate

Every AP sends one beacon per SSID about ten times a second, always at the lowest basic rate so every client can hear it. On 2.4 GHz only three channels don't overlap, so a client or AP hears many APs on its own channel.

BeaconWaiting before each beacon (DIFS)Left for everything else
One beacon takes
Airtime used by beacons
Compared with a 12 Mbps basic rate

2 · One slow client slows everyone down

Wi-Fi gives every station an equal chance to transmit, not equal time. When an old 802.11b device sends a frame, the air is busy for as long as that frame takes, and the modern client simply waits.

Old 802.11b client sends at
Old 802.11b clientModern client (802.11n MCS 7, 65 Mbps)Protection (CTS-to-self)ACKDIFS + backoff, SIFS
Modern client aloneno 802.11b devices allowed
Modern client, with one 802.11b client active
The old client's frame usesof each round's airtime

3 · Protection frames in front of every modern frame

An 802.11b device can't decode OFDM frames, so it can't tell the channel is busy. As soon as one is associated, the AP turns on protection: every OFDM sender first transmits a short CTS-to-self at an 802.11b rate that reserves the air. The 802.11b device doesn't even have to be sending anything.

CTS-to-self sent at
802.11g 54 Mbps, no protection1,500-byte frames, one client
With protection
Throughput lostjust because an 802.11b device is associated

4 · Bigger cells, more interference

The lower the basic rate, the further away a beacon can still be decoded. A 1 Mbps beacon reaches much further than a 12 Mbps one, so each AP's cell grows: clients stay attached to distant APs (see Sticky Clients and Minimum Basic Rate) and every AP interferes with more of its neighbours on the same channel.

That multiplies panel 1: the more APs each client can hear, the more beacons fill the air.

What to do

  • Disable 1, 2, 5.5 and 11 Mbps (and usually 6 and 9) on 2.4 GHz. Devices that only speak 802.11b are almost extinct.
  • Set the lowest basic rate to 12 or 24 Mbps. Check that the MBR edges of neighbouring APs still overlap.
  • Keep SSIDs to a minimum: every extra SSID adds a beacon per AP, ten times a second.
  • Consider 2.4 GHz for coverage only, with lower AP power and some 2.4 GHz radios turned off, and put capable clients on 5 and 6 GHz.

Notes and assumptions